The story behind the game
The second game of the 2008 women’s championship final in Nalchik finishes in a draw after an active, changing struggle. Exchanges transform the middlegame into a rook ending with dangerous pawns. Study how both players keep their pieces useful, then work through the repeated checking pattern instead of treating the result as an absence of ideas.
Take these ideas to your next game
- A useful exchange can reduce pressure without making every piece passive.
- Reassess the position after each central pawn contact.
- In a rook ending, checking distance and king squares matter as much as pawn count.
- A repeated checking pattern can be a successful defensive resource.
Read the complete annotated game
Full game transcript, including the result and the answers. Original explanations by chessgames.info; game score from the sources below.
Kosteniuk plays 24.Rd3, offering a rook exchange with an active bishop recapture. The recorded …Rxd3 is met by Bxd3. White reduces the number of heavy pieces without abandoning useful squares. Check the remaining central tension and Black’s pawn advances before assuming that an exchange automatically makes the position safe.
The move 36.c4 changes the pawn structure and prepares a different set of exchanges. Black responds …Qd6, and the queens are exchanged before cxb5. Follow the knight captures and the new passed-pawn possibilities after that, rather than applying the old middlegame evaluation to the ending. Every exchange changes which targets matter.
Kosteniuk plays 41.Nxf5, leading to a rook ending after the recorded recaptures. The sequence removes the remaining knights, but both rooks stay active and the pawn structure remains unbalanced. A simplified position still requires accurate defence. Use the saved alternatives to compare the king and rook tasks instead of assuming that fewer pieces mean an automatic draw.
White plays 53.Rc4+, beginning the checking pattern seen at the end of the score. The game repeats the king route between e4 and d3 while White’s rook checks from c4 and c3. The full move history matters for repetition; a board diagram alone is insufficient. Recognizing a stable drawing mechanism is a positive practical skill, not a failure to find a winning plan.
Result: 1/2-1/2. The recorded score ends here; it does not imply checkmate.
Think through the turning points
Move 24: Simplify with an active recapture
White’s rook is on d5. Which retreat offers an exchange while allowing the bishop to recapture actively? In the game: Rd3. Kosteniuk plays 24.Rd3, offering a rook exchange with an active bishop recapture. The recorded …Rxd3 is met by Bxd3. White reduces the number of heavy pieces without abandoning useful squares. Check the remaining central tension and Black’s pawn advances before assuming that an exchange automatically makes the position safe.
Engine-supported alternatives
Rd3 Rxd3 Bxd3 Rd8 c3 Bd5 Bc2 Be6 Qf3 Ne8 Qh5 Qb6 · +0.26 · depth 20
Rxd8+ Rxd8 Kc1 Kb8 c3 a6 Nf1 Rxd1+ Qxd1 Qd7 Qxd7 Bxd7 · +0.19 · depth 20
Qg4+ Kb8 · -0.05 · depth 20
Move 36: Challenge the centre again
Black has a knight on d4 and a pawn on b5. Which pawn move changes the central contact before the queen exchange? In the game: c4. The move 36.c4 changes the pawn structure and prepares a different set of exchanges. Black responds …Qd6, and the queens are exchanged before cxb5. Follow the knight captures and the new passed-pawn possibilities after that, rather than applying the old middlegame evaluation to the ending. Every exchange changes which targets matter.
Engine-supported alternatives
c4 Nxe2 Rxe2 bxc4 Rc2 Rd3 Nxf5 Qd7 Qxc4 Rd1+ Rc1 Rxc1+ · +1.87 · depth 19
c3 Nxe2 Rxe2 f4 gxf4 Qxf4 Qc5 Kb7 Rg2 Rd7 · +1.70 · depth 19
a4 bxa4 · +1.62 · depth 19
Move 41: Trade the knights into a rook ending
White’s knight is on e3. Which capture removes the f5-pawn and allows a sequence of knight exchanges? In the game: Nxf5. Kosteniuk plays 41.Nxf5, leading to a rook ending after the recorded recaptures. The sequence removes the remaining knights, but both rooks stay active and the pawn structure remains unbalanced. A simplified position still requires accurate defence. Use the saved alternatives to compare the king and rook tasks instead of assuming that fewer pieces mean an automatic draw.
Engine-supported alternatives
Nxf5 Rf6 Ne3 Rf3 Rxf3 gxf3 Kc1 Kxc6 Kd2 Kd6 h3 Ke5 · +2.90 · depth 19
Rc1 Nf3 Nxf5 Rd3 Rc3 Rxc3 bxc3 Nxh2 Kc2 Kxc6 Kd2 Nf3+ · +2.42 · depth 19
Rd1 · +2.29 · depth 19
Move 53: Find the repeatable check
Black’s king is on e4 and the rook is on c2. Which check begins the repeating defensive pattern? In the game: Rc4+. White plays 53.Rc4+, beginning the checking pattern seen at the end of the score. The game repeats the king route between e4 and d3 while White’s rook checks from c4 and c3. The full move history matters for repetition; a board diagram alone is insufficient. Recognizing a stable drawing mechanism is a positive practical skill, not a failure to find a winning plan.
Engine-supported alternatives
Rc4+ Kf3 Rf4+ Ke2 Rf6 Rc8+ Kb1 Rc5 b3 Re5 Kc2 Rc5+ · +0.00 · depth 26
Rc7 e2 Kc2 Rd1 Re7+ Kf3 a5 e1=Q Rxe1 Rxe1 Kd3 Rb1 · +0.00 · depth 26
a5 Kf3 Rc3 Kf2 Rc7 e2 Rf7+ Ke3 Re7+ Kd3 b3 Rd5 · +0.00 · depth 26
Every piece has a part to play.
The second game of the 2008 women’s championship final in Nalchik finishes in a draw after an active, changing struggle. Exchanges transform the middlegame into a rook ending with dangerous pawns. Study how both players keep their pieces useful, then work through the repeated checking pattern instead of treating the result as an absence of ideas.
Look a little deeper
Play on the board or type your move. Strong engine-supported alternatives receive credit.
Future moves stay hidden until you continue.
Try a different path.
Select a key moment to explore legal continuations supported by saved Stockfish analysis.
Accessible evaluation values & provenance
Stockfish 17.1 · 75,000 nodes per position; 1,000,000 at key moments. Actual depth 12–44. Positive centipawns favour White; mate scores remain separate. Selective search is evidence, not proof.
Download complete engine evidence